Geography 138
Political Ecology of the Third World
Summer 2006 - Session Two (July 3 - August 11)


Return to Summer 2006 Schedule


Instructor: Ben Gardner
email: gardnerb@berkeley.edu
office phone:
office:
office hours:
Class Location: 145 McCone
Class Time:
T,W,TH 9:00 - 11:30

Course control number: 48020
Units: 4

Course Description:
“Going up that river was like traveling back to the earliest beginnings of the world, when vegetation rioted the earth and the big trees were kings. An empty stream, a great silence, an impenetrable forest. The air was warm, thick, heavy, sluggish. There was no joy in the brilliance of sunshine. The long stretches of the waterway ran on, deserted into the gloom of overshadowed distances. On silvery sandbanks hippos and alligators sunned themselves side by side. The broadening waters flowed through a mob of wooded islands; you lost your way on that river as you would in a desert, and butted all day long against shoals, trying to find the channel, till you thought yourself bewitched and cut off for ever from everything you had known once.”
—Joseph Conrad, Heart of Darkness

Political Ecology rejects the view that environmental degradation can be understood as a set of objective problems amenable to scientific and technical fixes. It starts with the assumption that there are political, economic and social dynamics that are often left out of common understandings of ecology. This course introduces students to a set of conceptual tools to analyze the political, economic, and cultural contexts of natural resource use and management in the Third World. Political Ecologists view nature not a neutral terrain outside of human history and social relations, but as geographically and historically specific; it both shapes and is shaped by human desires, interests and actions.

The course begins by contrasting popular paradigms for understanding third world environmental change with a Political Ecology approach. We start with classical formulations of political ecology and work through newer work reflecting engagements with more sophisticated understandings of culture, space, place, power, gender, and race. We will work through a series of geographical and historical cases in Latin America, African and Asia, outlining key recurrent themes in the field (e.g. the critique of Malthusian perspectives on population growth’s relation to environmental problems, the denaturalization of environmental problems by focusing on social relations and history, a consistent emphasis on the politics of distribution, access to and control over resources, and the linking of environmental narratives of places, identities, and rights with certain understandings of Third World nations and peoples). Above all, students are asked to apply ideas from Political Ecology to analyze contemporary environmental problems.

Course Requirements:
*See separate “Course Policies and Expectations” handout for additional information

This is a reading and writing intensive course. Students must complete nightly readings, attend all lectures, and participate in discussions. In addition to this, there are three short essay assignments, a group project and in-class presentation, and an in-class final. Each writing assignment engages with the course readings (both required and supplemental), and does not require additional research. The final exam will consist of several short essay questions. You will be given the questions ahead of time.

Grading:
Breakdown of the Final Grade:

  • Essay 1 = 10%
  • Essay 2 = 10%
  • Essay 3 = 10%
  • Group Project = 30%
  • Final Exam = 25%
  • Class Participation = 15%

HANDOUTS DESCRIBING EACH OF THE ASSIGNMENTS WILL BE GIVEN OUT DURING THE FIRST WEEK OF CLASS.

Readings:
Required Readings
- These are marked with an asterisk in the course outline and must be carefully read before each day’s class. They are found in the course reader.

Supplemental Readings - These fall below the horizontal line in the Readings section of the schedule and provide important background for the lectures, but are not required. You may also want to take a look at them when preparing group projects or written assignments. They are on reserve in the Earth Sciences Library in McCone Hall.


Course Outline and Assignments:
In general, this six-week intensive course combines lecture, videos and small group discussion formats. Each 2 hour meeting is divided into two modules with a break in between. Each meeting has assigned readings listed under it—in order to comprehend lectures and participate in discussions students must come to class with those readings already prepared.
Date Topics Readings and Films
I. INTRODUCTION: POLITICAL ECOLOGY, POVERTY AND THE ENVIRONMENT
W 7/5 Popular Paradigms of Environmental Change
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Course Logistics
*Jared Diamond, 1999. Guns, Germs and Steel. (Pages 13-32, 53-66)

Ricardo Hausmann. Prisoners of Geography. Foreign Policy. 122: 44-54
Sachs, Jeffrey D. 2001. “Topical Underdevelopment.” NBER Working Paper 8119.
TH 7/6 Political Ecology: Intellectual Origins, Themes, and Tool-kit
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Small Group Discussion
Organize Group Projects
*Hecht. Susanna. 1985. “Environment, Development, and Politics.” World Development. 13:6
*Blakie, Piers and Harold Brookfield. 1985. Land Degradation and Society. (Introduction, Chapters 1-2)
Watts, Michael. “Political Ecology” in Companion to Economic Geography
Bryant, R. “A Political Ecology for Developing Countries?”
Mike Davis. “Origins of the Third World.” Antipode 32 (1) 48-89
II. AMAZON BASIN: INDIGENOUS PEOPLE, RESOURCE EXTRACTION
AND THE PRODUCTION OF TROPICALITY
T 7/11 Critical Natural Histories of the Amazonian Landscape
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Discussion
*Candace Slater. "Amazonia as Edenic Narrative". In Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human: Place on Nature, edited by William Cronon. (Pages 114-131)
*Raymond Williams. “Ideas of Nature”. In Problems in Materialism and Culture. (pages 67-82)

Stepan, Nancy. 2001. Picturing Tropical Nature. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. (Intro)
Hugh Raffles. The Uses of Butterflies in In Amazonia. (Pages114-149)
Adam Hochschild. King Leopold’s Ghost. (Pages 140-149)
W 7/12 Finding Eden, Tapping Rubber and the Geographical Imaginary of the Rainforest
Part 1: Video
Part 2: Discussion
Video:
*Fitzcarraldo by Werner Herzog
*Burden of Dreams by Les Blanc
Reading:
*Michael Brown and Eduardo Fernandez. War of the Shadows: The Struggle for Utopia in the
Peruvian Amazon. (Pages 211-217)
TH 7/13 Environmental Politics and the Burden of Indigenous People (First Essay Due)
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Discussion
*Susanna Hecht and Alexander Cockburn. "Defenders of the Amazon". Chapter 8 in The Fate of the Forest: Developers, Destroyers and Defenders of the Amazon. (Pages 180-216)
*Beth Conklin and Laura Graham. “Amazonian Indians and Eco-Politics”. American Anthropologist 97 (4) 695-710

Tsing, Anna. 1999. “Becoming a Tribal Elder and Other Green Development Fantasies.” in Li Transforming the Indonesian Uplands.
Joe Kane. Savages. 1-32, 251-255.
"On the Front Lines But Struggling for Voice: Women in the Rubber Tappers’ Defence of the Amazon Forest". The Ecologist 27(2): 46-54.
III. WRESTLING MALTHUS
T 7/18 Famine and Population: A Political Ecology of Mass Starvation in Colonial India
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Discussion
*Ross, Eric B. (2000). “The Malthus Factor: Poverty, Politics and Population in Capitalist Development,” Briefing 20. Dorset, UK: The Corner House.
http://www.thecornerhouse.org.uk/briefing/index.shtml
*Davis, Mike. 2001. Late Victorian Holocausts. New York: Verso. (p. 25-59, 311-340).
Watts, Michael. 1983. Silent Violence. Berkeley: UC Press. (Chapter 7).
Malthus, Thomas. 1826. An Essay on the Principle of Population. London: John Murray. (1-24)
W 7/19 Drought, Capitalism and the Politics of Hunger
Part 1: Video
Part 2: Discussion
Time for group projects
Video:
*
One Hundred Years of Drought
TH 7/20 Seed Wars and the New Genetic Enclosures (Second Essay Due)
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Discussion
Course Evaluation and Feedback
*Kloppenberg, Jack. 1988. First the Seed. Cambridge: Cambridge UP (Chapter 7 and selections)
*Mittal, Anuranda and Peter Rosset. 2002. “Genetic Engineering and the Privatization of Seeds.” Dollars and Sense. April 30.
*Conko, Gregory. and C.S. Prakash. 2002. “Battling Hunger with Biotechnology.”

Altieri, Miguel A., and Peter Rosset (1999). “Ten Reasons Why Biotechnology Will Not Ensure Food Security, Protect the Environment and Reduce Poverty in the Developing World,” AgBioForum 2 (3-4) 155-62. [5] http://www.agroeco.org
Boal, Ian 2001. “Damaging Crops.” in Peluso and Watts Violent Environments
IV. NATIONAL PARKS AND THE POLITICS OF CONSERVATION IN AFRICA
T 7/25 Finding Wilderness By Enclosing It
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Discussion
*Roderick Neumann. Imposing Wilderness. (Pages 97-156)
*William Beinart. "Debating Conservation in the African Areas of the Cape 1920-1950". (Pages 332-366). In The Rise of Conservation in South Africa: Settlers, Livestock, and the Environment 1770-1950.

Marx, Karl. “The Secret of Primitive Accumulation” and “The Expropriation of the Agricultural Population from the Land.” Capital. p.874-895.
Thompson, E.P. 1975. Whigs and Hunters (Chapters 1,3,7,9)
Peter Little. "Rethinking Interdisciplinary Paradigms and the Political Ecology of Pastoralism in East Africa". In African Savannas: Global Narratives and Local Knowledge of Environmental Change. Editors Thomas J. Bassett and Donald Crummey.
W 7/26 Producing Nature in Africa: Land Rights and Colonial Conservation
Part 1: Video
Part 2: Discussion
Video:
*
Tchuma-Tchato
Reading:
*Max Chapin. “A Challenge to Conservationists”. World Watch, Nov./Dec. 2004
TH 7/27 Communities, Conservation and Rights: The Role of Community Resource Management in State-Society Relations (Third Essay Due)
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Discussion
*Daniel Brockington. "The Contingency of Community Conservation". Pp. 100-120. In Rural Resources and Local Livelihoods in Africa, Edited by Katherine Homewood.
*Peluso, Nancy. 1993. “Coercing Conservation?” Global Environmental Change. June. (Pages 199-217)
Brandon, Katrina and Michael Wells. 1992. “Planning for People and Parks.” World Development Vol 20. No. 4 pp. 557-570.
Cronon, William (1996). “The Trouble with Wilderness; or, Getting Back to the Wrong Nature,” in William Cronon, ed., Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature. (69-90).
V. NATURE AND NATION IN SOUTHEAST ASIA
T 8/1 Forests, Dams and Expertise in South and Southeast Asian Development
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Discussion
*Nancy Peluso. Rich Forests and Poor People. pp. 3-24
*K. Sivaramakrishnan. State Science and Joint Forest Management. Development and Change 31 (1) 61-89
James McCarthy. "Devolution in the Woods". Environment and Planning A June 2005
James McCarthy. "Neo-liberal Nature". Geoforum 35 (3) 275-283
W 8/2 The Nature of Civil Society
Part 1: Video
Part 2: Class time for group projects
Video:
*
A Narmada Diary
TH 8/3 Social Relations of Resistance: Gender, Ethnicity and Corruption
Part 1: Lecture
Part 2: Discussion
Course Evaluation and Feedback
*Hapriya Rangan. Of Myths and Movements. (Pages 151-174)
*Paul Robbins. “The Rotten Institution: Corruption in Natural Resource Management”. Political Geography 19 (4) 423-443
Baviskar, Amita. 2001. “Claims to Knowledge, Claims to Control.” in Ellen, Roy, Peter Parkes, and Alan Bicker eds. Indigenous Environmental Knowledge and its Transformations: Critical Anthropological Perspectives. Amsterdam: Hardwood.

Larry Loehman. "Forest Cleansing: Racial Oppression in Scientific Nature Conservation". The Corner House Briefing [13]. http://www.thecornerhouse.org.uk/item.shtml?x=51969
VI: POLITICAL ECOLOGY: PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS
T 8/10 Group Presentations
W 8/11 Conclusion: What is Political Ecology, and What is it Good For?
TH 8/12 Final Exam in Class
Return to top